I'm not convinced that the footage is not just shot off of the screen at the concert with a soundboard audio dubbed over it.

Couple things:

1. If you're Duff, would you be ok with not playing the basslines that you wrote? I get if he wants to do rhythm with AIC like he's done in the past, but not with GnR.

2. Not a snowball's chance in hell they play CD songs if they reunite. Axl barely plays them in the first place. I mean, maybe a stripped down TIL with just Fortus on guitar. Slash would maybe consider it, but only if Axl sang some of his shit, and we know that Axl's not about to bust out Fall to Pieces or Back to Cali.

3. The more I think about it, the more I think Frank is the most likely drummer at this point. I honestly don't think they'd even want to make a choice between Adler and Matt (which would most likely be Matt) so just stick with Frank.

Bottom line - the only thing the public would care about is that Axl singing (however poorly that may be) and Slash is playing guitar on the classic songs they know. Maybe some people on Blabbermouth comments section would cry foul without Duff, Izzy, or Popcorn, but GNR with Axl and Slash with 3-4 other generics would sell out arenas in a heartbeat.

One of the things I keep coming back to when it comes to a reunion is Axl's relationship with Tommy. Duff is the easiest member for Axl to reunite with, but Tommy has been there since the day Duff left.

Tommy may be ready to move on judging by all his Replacements engagements, but I don't think Axl would EVER dump Tommy to reunite with the OG's.

Alright just throwing it out there...could be Ashba.