Tmgladden wrote:

Sky Dog wrote:

I think all the original stuff will surface at some point on a huge boxset. Why not?

Now is not the time. Once the reunion happened, CD2 was toast. It’s unfortunate because I want the dudes on there who wrote it.

I feel the same way. It’s great we get official reworking, but man the originals are just so much better. Maybe minus absurd, silkworms was better

Silkworms is a million times better than absurd
Absurd is way too repetive
And its still dumb they took out the chorus

Shacklermyrye wrote:

What there doing now is basically what Ron said they should do back then, drop a few songs at a time. They should have done this years ago

Tbh, I thought it was dumb when he suggested it

I think Ron’s goal was to release the “old stuff” and record new songs for a new album, which was never gonna happen for him. I can see Slash wanting something similar, the difference being Slash is getting songwriting credit on the “old stuff.”

carlossacanell wrote:

Why are we assuming they Will never sound like AFD? I don't mean in term of hits but the sound. This is in their hands...

They can't sound like AFD because they're not in their 20s, Izzy and Adler aren't in the band, Axl Slash and Duff have written a grand total of zero songs together without Izzy, and they never have anyone who can produce and mix anything that will sound that good.

thiago wrote:

dave-gnfnr wrote:

The reason why no one cares is bc it does not sound like AFD Gnr.  Its just Slash and Duffs take on the CD era stuff
Until they all actualy write new stuff together that sounds like classic GNR, no one will care.

They will never sound like AFD again, and that's OK

Yet that is what all the fans want, that sound for new songs or they will never be happy