I think the ASCAP version credits anyone who came up with anything included on the song. Shacklers is a Bucket and Brain song that they brought in but Finck has a credit as a song writer for it by ASCAP, surely his credit is because of that little solo he plays at the very end?

In makingfuckingvideos, Duff talks about how Axl came up with Estranged on the piano and how he and Slash had to translate what he was playing into guitar language, he made it sound like all the melodies were there on the piano version.
I agree it would have been fairier if everyone had been credited in the booklet for what they contributed though, but I'm not suprised in the slightest to see other credits coz Axl dont play the drums, bass, keyboards or guitar in the band.

Good looking wee dog, she has lovely colouring. Congrats!!!

How many rounds are left before the final?

So what position is it now?

For some reason I can hear that song "downtown" in my head even as I ask

Man there are far worse folk than D who post on the boards reguarly and beat out the same tired old tune, but when he does it, folk fall over themselves to stick the boot in and have a good laugh at his expense. Thought I was reading a typically bollocks thread at htgth for a moment there.

Prince was probably pished:D