AtariLegend wrote:

James Lofton wrote:

Using fucked up logic in a losing argument. Maybe all the boards should shut down since Slash knows more than any of us.

That's your comeback line...

Hmmmmm...

I basically said the same thing as you to show you the absurdity of it. If you have a problem with it, go look in the mirror.

Couple of other juicy nuggets from the mind of atarilegend and apparently Marc Canter as well.....

Tobias played on the original demos, Slash did re-do it in his own style... but he was for the most part playing parts already created by some one else

Creativity is creating the music not playing it.

Played the original/created the guitar parts. If we went by who has credit on a sleeve as the song writer... Axl would un-doubly be the greatest multi-instrumentalist of all time.

I think you'd jump off a bridge if the end result was Slash losing a few songwriting credits.

war wrote:

The contents of this thread are hilarious

We've went from not giving Axl enough credit to giving Slash too much credit, and now apparently Tobias was the mastermind of GNR.

I like Tobias. For years I have wanted him to come back. I just think its insane that some people try and diminish what the original line up contributed.