People, there's no point in members going at each other over personal taste...its what makes the world go around.

Plus, every one of our heros in this band (old and new) are old and and loosing pieces of what they were that made us love them, some more than others (I'm looking at you Axl Rose) but still, we don't know what's up there. It could be food adddiction, booze, pills, meds, thyroid failure, diabetes...who the fuck knows....?

To get to some of the many topics in this thread...

Myles is technically brilliant but like many of you I find the nasal quality really annoying. He should do what Mike Patton did between The Real Thing and  Angel Dust, retrain your voice and get rid of that bad timbre.

Each to their own though...he is working at the highest level in the Rock Industry and seems like a nice bloke so hats off to him.

regarding asking Slash back...

1.
After RNRHOF Slash said he was "done" with the whole thing. I don't believe Slash has it in him to tour for 2 years on a knife edge with a lead singer that may or may not show or worse, turn on him half way through the trip. I bet he's making plenty of $$$ without Axl Rose being in his life.

2.
No man from the old GNR will take ANY orders from Team Brazil. After the way they hung Slash out to dry when he showed up at the house looking to meet Axl, I doubt Slash would even entertain a call from those people. Likewise, I would not expect a mature adult and astute businessman like Duff swallow that turd burger either.

3.
Who the fuck wants to work with people in their thirties, forties and fifties who keep lists of their "enemies" or "devils" ?

4.
What record company / promoter would lay down €150M in advance for this tour at this time? Would you if you were asked? Most of those big money talks were years ago at this stage anway.

5.
What would a reunited band bring to the fan? Axl's been on the Greatest Hits tour forever..would the millions of fans turn out around the world for this AGAIN..even with the old guys?

6.
Would Axl do interviews, articles, podcasts, tweets, etc to promote this? Would he and Slash be willing to eat some crow and be gracious and decent about each other?

7.
Who would be the manager, tour manager etc?

You bundle all of that together and I just cannot see why anyone would be bothered trying to gather this thing to together and driving it home.

zep didn't accomplish more. gnr did in one album what it took zep to do in 6 or 7, what it took the stones to do in 10 or 12.

imo there's no contest. i love zep. but they're quite easily second best in this discussion.

you don't get points for longevity. in a battle of sheer brilliance it's guns all the way.