Bill Brasky wrote:

dave-gnfnr wrote:

What was the example? And dont tell me it was the That he's seen or heard no evidence of other songs.

Because someone said they think there are other songs out there and then saying that he's hasn't seen or heard no evidence of other songs is not a contradiction

One is your opinion like oh I think there are aliens out there
then saying I have not seen or heard any evidence of aliens

So saying in a private group that you have heard unreleased songs then denying it publicly by putting caveats on your prior statements is what liars do.

I don't understand your confusion.

Someone can claim oh this is a new GNR song, and play it over the phone. You do know it could be a fake right? And if it cant be verify it's not a lie to saying you dont KNOW if anything is out there. 

Not sure why you are confused on this. There is a huge difference between KNOWING something for sure and someone claiming oh this is new GNR.

How many fakes of GNR stuff is out there, a lot.

for example, look at that clip of Closing it on you.
If I called Dark and said oh here is a unreleased GNR song,  no one KNOWs if that song is legit or if its a fake, but just because I played it for him claiming its GNR, that doesnt mean he KNOWS there are leakes out there bc he is not sure if what I played him is legit or not.

so to recap, just because someone claimed to play him unreleased GNR songs that does not mean someone KNOWS there are legit other songs out there.

Its not that confusing.

Bill Brasky wrote:

dave-gnfnr wrote:

Nothing dark has said has been a lie
thus why I am asking if Axl S thinks he lied then I wanted to example to see what he thought a lie was

And how would you know what he's said to other people then yourself ?

that is why I am asking Axl S to give examples of what these supposed lies are. Instead of just making a claim and not backing it up.
since nothing Dark has said to me or that I have seen him post on these forums have been a lie

Bill Brasky wrote:

dave-gnfnr wrote:

Why did you just repeat yourself
I wanted you to explain it better with evidence or examples of why you think he is lying

Give examples of how you think he lied?

You do understand he could think there is other stuff out there but has no evidence to back up that claim.

Its like I have no evidence there are aliens but I think aliens are out there.

Ummmm there was this group
That went by a certain name
I can verify  Axl s would have knowledge
Of what was said in that group as im sure others can also.

Friendly fire Dave.
Now Dave is good guy and so is Axl S
You both want the same things.

Nothing dark has said has been a lie
thus why I am asking if Axl S thinks he lied then I wanted to example to see what he thought a lie was

Axl S wrote:

dave-gnfnr wrote:

How is he lying?

That he's seen or heard no evidence of other songs.

Either he's lying now, or he's telling the truth and he lied to me in the past.

Why did you just repeat yourself
I wanted you to explain it better with evidence or examples of why you think he is lying

Give examples of how you think he lied?

You do understand he could think there is other stuff out there but has no evidence to back up that claim.

Its like I have no evidence there are aliens but I think aliens are out there.

Bill Brasky wrote:

AgesOfTheIce wrote:

Bird (the guy who bought the locker) made up all that shit about having more Village discs with stuff like Oklahoma & Zodiac with vocals because he didn't want people to know everything he had had been leaked. Rick swore up and down that Bird had all these unleaked tracks (like Dragon, whatever the fuck that was supposed to be) but when pressed if he had actually heard any of this stuff to verify it he didn't answer, which answers the question itself imo.

The more village disc statement has nothing to due with Bird or Rick's statements.

Don't believe the narrative that has been pushed out by propagandist

Leaks that occurred prior to Bird or Rick getting  the village leaks are exact dat matches to Village locker leaks.

Here's a idea , why doesn't someone contact individuals that worked on the village sessions. Hell ask Fernando on reddit , band members  or producers ect.... not named Zoutat.

This forum is the home of Chinese Whispers right ? So it's capable of finding out The real Truth.

This has been done a few time's over the years. Contact details are public for them. Some have spoken here and there, Sp!at did well with this years ago. You would be best off talking to anyone who has worked on that stuff & then retired since. There not going to jeopardize there ability to get work, Even if there weren't NDA's many just consider if a professional courtesy not to speak.