You are not logged in. Please register or login.

#5232 Re: Guns N' Roses » Brain in Modern Drummer (May 2009) » 891 weeks ago

All the promotion in the world wouldn't change anything.  This is not AC/DC - not even close - even if you ignore the different eras.  Anything short of Axl and Slash will not equal GnR to the public, therefore will not be accepted, nor will it sell.  CD = Contraband...some sales due to the curiosity factor.  If there is a next album, consider it Libertad (which I like, but it was clearly a failure).  They could promote the shit out of whatever band they have together at the moment and it wouldn't matter.  Half of them weren't featured on the existing album and if there's ever another album, half of them won't be on that album either.  And nobody is waiting 15 years for another Axl Rose record, so anyone that thinks they can rebuild the hype is mistaken.

The album that just came out only really has Axl, Tommy, Dizzy and Pitman making significant contributions with other additions forced in here and there for some reason that is completely beyond comprehension.  Until otherwise proven, there's no Brain, huge, BH, or Finck in GnR anymore.  There are as many contributors still in the band as there are out of it.  There's no way you can compare this to AC/DC, which really became famous after Bon died.  The best AC/DC / GnR comparison would be the Ole Bach era to the AFD era.

#5233 Re: The Garden » Am I Moving in on his Girl? » 891 weeks ago

Remember Dr Drew and Adam on Loveline?  They would make bets on stuff like this.  Chicks that seek out the chaos will seek out the chaos again.  They know it's not good for them, but they always go back.

#5234 Re: Guns N' Roses » Brain in Modern Drummer (May 2009) » 891 weeks ago

AC/DC is completely different.  AC/DC lost one guy in a band that was known, but not huge 5 years before video even made who was in a band common knowledge.  Fast forward to the video era where GnR was for a short period of time the biggest in the world now replacing every single person other than the singer from their landmark album that used videos to identify who they were.  It's not even apples and oranges.  Journey, Styx, Motley Crue, Poison...the list goes on and on for 80s bands that were never given a chance without the lineup that made the band famous.  Had Bon died post AC/DC really making it, they would have had the same fate with Brian Johnson.

Video changed all the rules - names suddenly had faces beyond the lead singer.  Once that happened, it changed the entire complexion of the music industry in so many ways.

#5235 Re: Guns N' Roses » Brain in Modern Drummer (May 2009) » 891 weeks ago

Only one thing can take them back to superstardom, and I don't even really think that could do it anymore other than as a nostalgia act.  It's time to face it, GnR is done and has been for years.  That may have happened anyway had the original band not split, but NO band has ever accomplished anything after such a monumental start and disappearing for 15 years only to re-emerge with a completely different band. 

I have no idea why anybody expected GnR to be different.  The public wants what they consider to be the real GnR.  Nothing Axl or Azoff does is going to change that.  I said this years ago: very, very few kids are looking for a man approaching 50 to save rock.  No kids = no commercial success = no record contract.  The end is very near.

#5236 Re: The Garden » Warship arrives as pirates’ options dwindle » 891 weeks ago

I don't believe Bush made up stories about terrorists.  Exaggerated?  Maybe, but there was and still is a clear terrorist threat in Iraq.  If not, Obama wouldn't have backed off his timeline for leaving Iraq.

#5237 Re: Guns N' Roses » Chinese Democracy/Rock Band 2 (Tracks Leaking?) » 892 weeks ago

NY Giants82 wrote:

All i have is a PS2. I wasnt planning on "upgrading" because I was content to just play Madden on my PS2. Now, I'm REALLY contemplating getting a PS3... for this!

Don't do it.  Find a freind that has it and play it there.

#5238 Re: The Garden » Warship arrives as pirates’ options dwindle » 892 weeks ago

Bush = terrorists
Obama = pirates

The more things change, the more they stay the same.

#5239 Re: Guns N' Roses » Chinese Democracy/Rock Band 2 (Tracks Leaking?) » 892 weeks ago

Off topic - survived the tornado as did everybody I know (so far).  I have nothing to add on topic, so carry on.

#5240 Re: Guns N' Roses » Chinese Democracy/Rock Band 2 (Tracks Leaking?) » 892 weeks ago

russtcb wrote:
buzzsaw wrote:

Cool - it will only cost me 4 bucks to get the only 2 songs worth having.

Just curious, but which two songs? I'm sure you've said it before but I don't remember what they were.

Off the top of my head, if I had to pick 2 and only 2 it'd be Better and TWAT.

Correct - gotta go dodge a tornado.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB