war wrote:

i agree with most of that but i prefer 2010.

the tiebreaker for me was i feel he had more tone to his voice in 2010 - a little flat at times in 2006

Yeah but I think there are times on the rockers in 2010 he puts more pressure on his vocals, and frankly sounds like he's taking a shit while singing.

I gotta be honest, I really cannot stand the 2009-11 performances of CD-the song.

Really REALLY liked the 2006 performances better. More rasp than 2002, less "cat in heat" than 2010.

Hopefully after Rio... that's a good thing.