You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
Re: LEAKS THREAD
Please sir, may I have some more?
That's why I think this could be from 2000. And, like Zombux said, by that time the producer was Roy Thomas Baker.
might be one of those versions that had Robin deleted - after he left the band in 1999, with some later touches by RTB in 2000/2001, regardless of that Robin got back by that time.
I bet this version was sent to Robin by this fancy new contraption
"Hey Robin, FedEX your rhythm parts overnight!"
Re: LEAKS THREAD
Could anybody hit me up? Not heard it yet!
the link is publicly at mygnr and even the admins don't care about deleting it... http://www.mygnrforum.com/topic/219471- … ar-leaked/
- MrMiniMite
- Rep: 0
Re: LEAKS THREAD
MrMiniMite wrote:Could anybody hit me up? Not heard it yet!
the link is publicly at mygnr and even the admins don't care about deleting it... http://www.mygnrforum.com/topic/219471- … ar-leaked/
Thanks!
Re: LEAKS THREAD
aaaaaand it's gone, as the admins decided to play it safer - can't really blame them, Team Brazil is mad enough to go banzai about an old version of a song we heard 10000 times.
if it was something unheard, I'd get it. with this - just a storm in a glass of water 
- Voodoochild
- Rep: 3
Re: LEAKS THREAD
I like the mixing more than the album version but the guitars are lacking in this version, if someone like evader can add in robins and BHs missing guitar parts, I think it would be way better.
If the album version was mixed like this version it would be way better.
The thing that makes me not like this version is the mess of a rhythem guitar player.
And I agree with you, this could be a cut from what Robin was not in the band, because when Robin left the band BH redid all his parts and Robin was removed
that mess of a guitar is paul or axl
It may be just Axl's idea of what he would like in that particular section. The final version indeed has a somewhat similar guitar lead, although much better played, of course.
might be one of those versions that had Robin deleted - after he left the band in 1999, with some later touches by RTB in 2000/2001, regardless of that Robin got back by that time.
Yep. But it's different from what we got previously. We had IRS (both in 1999 and 2000-ish) that still had tons of Robin's leads. Catcher 99 still had Robin's leads mixed with May's solos. TWAT too still had Robin. It's not like he was erased, he was still there - much like Bucket was still very much present in almost all of the final album.
- dave-gnfnr
- Rep: 16
Re: LEAKS THREAD
dave-gnfnr wrote:I like the mixing more than the album version but the guitars are lacking in this version, if someone like evader can add in robins and BHs missing guitar parts, I think it would be way better.
If the album version was mixed like this version it would be way better.
The thing that makes me not like this version is the mess of a rhythem guitar player.
And I agree with you, this could be a cut from what Robin was not in the band, because when Robin left the band BH redid all his parts and Robin was removed
that mess of a guitar is paul or axl
It may be just Axl's idea of what he would like in that particular section. The final version indeed has a somewhat similar guitar lead, although much better played, of course.
zombux wrote:might be one of those versions that had Robin deleted - after he left the band in 1999, with some later touches by RTB in 2000/2001, regardless of that Robin got back by that time.
Yep. But it's different from what we got previously. We had IRS (both in 1999 and 2000-ish) that still had tons of Robin's leads. Catcher 99 still had Robin's leads mixed with May's solos. TWAT too still had Robin. It's not like he was erased, he was still there - much like Bucket was still very much present in almost all of the final album.
The TWAT and IRS 99 leaks are from before BH joined the band.
There are cuts of these songs without Robin. But the question is does anyone have them.
It all depends on that version of the song it is, there is like 15 versions of each song. Both Fortus and Dizzy confirmed this.
Re: LEAKS THREAD
Agreed, the guitar work is a bit of a mess and at some places also the synths need a little correction. The mix nevertheless sounds more exciting and fresh to me than the 2006 or final versions.
Just kinda underlines the assumption that the album would have sounded better in 2002/03...
