Board footer

supaplex

 Rep: 57 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

supaplex wrote:

i went for better although i know i'm fighting a lost battle and this will be the winner

my favorites are maddy and cd but i know those will be the next to go in that order. oh, well...

A Private Eye

 Rep: 77 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

A Private Eye wrote:

I voted off Madagascar.

DCK

 Rep: 207 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

DCK wrote:

I used to love Madgascar but the studio version doesn't really make it...

elmir

 Rep: 53 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

elmir wrote:

Maddy for me too....its gotta go...

Will

 Rep: 227 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

Will wrote:

Chi Dem got my vote.

-Jack-

 Rep: 39 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

-Jack- wrote:

CD is not that great. Been voting for it since round 1.

But seriously, none of the new GNR songs are that great.. I could have voted any of them off day 1 had I been in a different mood -_-.

Neemo

 Rep: 485 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

Neemo wrote:

CD for me honestly it was between that and better but seeing all the CD votes helped me make up my mind

Sky Dog

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

Sky Dog wrote:

I love the ideas behind Maddy and the direct, simple, heartfelt lyrics. I would eliminate the MLK quotes, but keep the movie stuff. However, the studio version has a horrible vocal (especially the 16 Axl's at the end) and very pitchy, whiny guitars in spots.

polluxlm

 Rep: 221 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

polluxlm wrote:

These four + The Blues are all pretty equal in quality.

Madagascar for the simple reason that the others are slightly better. Very slightly.

PaSnow

 Rep: 205 

Re: Chinese Democracy Elimination- Round 6

PaSnow wrote:

Maddy, good grief I'm beginning to hate this song even more now & I haven't listened to it in 2 weeks.

THe Blues?? WTF. That's the best song on there!!