Board footer

misterID

 Rep: 475 

Re: Article and review of CD in the Guardian

misterID wrote:

That was CD album review? Where? She only mentioned one song.

Mikkamakka

 Rep: 217 

Re: Article and review of CD in the Guardian

Mikkamakka wrote:

My problem with this is it isn't a review.  I'd have no problem if that had talked about the songs and why they thought it sucked.

Exactly. I wouldn't really mind about reviews if these weren't influating people to buy or not to buy something. I like to make my own opinion, but to tell the truth sometimes a very good review is inspiring and a very bad takes you away from even downloading the album (to 'taste it'). I can handle critical reviews, if the writer has fair points. Maybe he/she has a different view and a different taste in music, that's all. But this 'review' is absolutely shitty, the author has no clue. Wonder how Guardian could have accepted it.

-Jack-

 Rep: 39 

Re: Article and review of CD in the Guardian

-Jack- wrote:

lol.. it's funny because the guy is rating something he probably hasn't even listened to. What a clown. If you dislike the music, fine, who cares, but at least review something...

deadsouth

 Rep: 10 

Re: Article and review of CD in the Guardian

deadsouth wrote:

Whats the source of that Bon Jovi quote???

Axl S

 Rep: 112 

Re: Article and review of CD in the Guardian

Axl S wrote:

It was said in 2006. I remember reading about it on the forums.

nugdafied

Re: Article and review of CD in the Guardian

nugdafied wrote:

Whats the source of that Bon Jovi quote???

Are you joking? How do the fat internet kids even say newb these days?

DCK

 Rep: 207 

Re: Article and review of CD in the Guardian

DCK wrote:

That was a review out of nothing. Could have been written in 2001 and just put aside and waited for the release. Pretty fucking bad journalism.

deadsouth

 Rep: 10 

Re: Article and review of CD in the Guardian

deadsouth wrote:

Whats the source of that Bon Jovi quote???

Are you joking? How do the fat internet kids even say newb these days?

Excuse the fuck outta me...

Axl S

 Rep: 112 

Re: Article and review of CD in the Guardian

Axl S wrote:

Whats the source of that Bon Jovi quote???

Are you joking? How do the fat internet kids even say newb these days?

Cool it. He asked a perfectly fine question. Why so elitist?

A Private Eye

 Rep: 77 

Re: Article and review of CD in the Guardian

A Private Eye wrote:

That was CD album review? Where? She only mentioned one song.

The top piece wasn't a review it was an article just about Axls return and how it's good to see him back, even if there are a few scathing jokes aimed in his direction.

The second piece is the album review by a different journalist it just happened to be in the same newspaper on the same day so I posted both articles together.