why not detroit or houston shows from 2016? they filmed everything... and release this?

the mix makes slash sound like me when i was 13 years old pretending to be slash. axl hates so trump so much he turned into him.

i can't even get through double talking jive... sounds like slash's guitar is plugged into a sega genesis. what the fuck is wrong with this band?

fuck this band all the way to hell.

between this, no album & a children's book... no reason to continue supporting these clowns.

"just shut up & sing..."

same, the roxy soundboard especially

missed it in all the chaos last year

doesn't make any sense! this is the definitive version of arguably the most timeless song on the album.

"perhaps" is an unspired axl trying to force a cool piano riff into estranged junior.

atlas is great, but it's almost a b-side of catcher.

i might be crazy, but perhaps just doesn't really do it for me.

the piano parts are dope as fuck, but the hay haaays and the uninspired lyrics kill the song for me.

the chorus is also pretty weak. i'm just not feeling this song yet.

atlas has been stuck in my head permanently after the first few listens.