It fits in with Eye On You, hard to see how it fits in with Thyme though.

If the Rough Mixes hadn't been dropped, I wouldn't have believed this was GN'R.

edit

Ermm. I thought about it and I'm not sure how my original conclusion came about.

Worth pointing, I went back to the old mygnr thread with wes and it was claimed he actually had the 2006 leaks since nov. 04. So just for reference with the time line of those mixes and lack of the orchestra arangements, they were probably 02.

btw Was going to start a thread on it, but ended up doing this series instead.

What do you guys think Erzin's 2 songs were?

The Blues, Perhaps?

Art is subjective, but there's more than 2 tracks.

20 year old demos, most are instrumentals from a now defunct band. Atlas Shrugged/Silkworms were supposedly in circulation for years, most just didn't get them. Classic Rock heard them years ago, supposedly so did Mick Wall? Hardschool was presumably as well (checkmate). A different Silkworms demo was leaked years ago too as was Goin' Down.

So I guess that leaves State of Grace, Nothing, Perhaps and Tommy Demo 1. It's just not a big deal, unless you've been following along with the saga. The media intrique with the album was lost when it was released.

Elvis for example is awesome, but the only person on that track if at all, still in the band is Dizzy Reed.

I think this is a pretty strong record. I voted off Silkworms, even though I kind of like this version. I dig Ryiad as well, always have.. but every other track up there is as good as it gets.

It'll be interesting to see what makes the later stages. How does Perhaps and Atlas Shrugged fare against The Blues and There Was A Time. If Ryiad and Silkworms go first/second, what's third?