You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
#751 Re: Guns N' Roses » Better, As it Began instrumentals » 372 weeks ago
Buckethead made the material better, though it was fine as it was.
Bumblefoot made the material worse. Yes, he was fantastic for the community. However not for for songs.
I think it's acceptable if they wait till 2002, only because Buckethead and perhaps whatever Beltrami added. However these tracks still should have been released in 2000.
I really hope we hear that This I Love that was rejected for What Dreams May Come in 98 one day.
#752 Re: Guns N' Roses » Chinese Democracy tracklist - 2000 ~ 2001 » 373 weeks ago
AtariLegend wrote:James wrote:Oklahoma was a finished track at that point.
Wasn't sure if it was then, 02 or 06. I'm guessing given the dates it's probable a finished version of this was played for Erzin too.
It's on the same cd as Hardschool but by March 2000 it was still instrumentals only:
http://www.suicideshift.info/discograph … s-cd-3.png
Yeah, but rir was 1st jan 01.
The Erzin intervention was somewhere during that fall of 2000 so there's time (several months).
Couldn't have just been an instrumental at that point (erzin's review) if they were planned to play it live less than a few months later.
The version of Oklahoma played for Rolling Stone the year before, was supposedly an instrumental though. Maybe the same one on those discs if it ever leaks.
#753 Re: Guns N' Roses » Chinese Democracy tracklist - 2000 ~ 2001 » 373 weeks ago
Oklahoma was a finished track at that point.
Wasn't sure if it was then, 02 or 06. I'm guessing given the dates it's probable a finished version of this was played for Erzin too.
#754 Re: Guns N' Roses » the atlas shrugged remix made by imsorry » 373 weeks ago
No idea what this is about, but perhaps it'd be easier to just pm imsorry if such a thing exists.
He does post here and login regularly.
Personally I'm not big on remixs.
#755 Re: Guns N' Roses » Chinese Democracy tracklist - 2000 ~ 2001 » 373 weeks ago
For those with better memory, was Oklahoma on the 2001 setlists?
#756 Re: Guns N' Roses » Chinese Democracy tracklist - 2000 ~ 2001 » 373 weeks ago
Not sure about this order, but:
Chinese Democracy
Rhiad and the Bedouins
I.R.S.
The Blues
There Was A Time
Perhaps
Hard School
Madagascar
Prostitute
Catcher
-edit-
Gave some more thought to it. Lofton's right.
Left This I Love of this listing. This I Love we know existed in some form in the mid 90's, but it didn't seem to come in to play again until later on.
#757 Re: Guns N' Roses » Better, As it Began instrumentals » 373 weeks ago
Yeah Axl was right.
For a good laugh, read through this;
#758 Re: Guns N' Roses » Insert your leak here » 373 weeks ago
Please don't post a thread like this unless there's a leak or for geniune discussion.
Waste of everyone's time.
#759 Re: Guns N' Roses » Drain the Swamp? » 373 weeks ago
Listening to that supposed phone call.
Cannot believe it isn't trolling, otherwise the parties involved aren't the brightest for tapping it.
#760 Re: Guns N' Roses » Better, As it Began instrumentals » 373 weeks ago
2-3 is a stretch.
You've got:
The Blues
CITR
TIL
Prostitute
Better &/or CDWhich, for all intents & purposes, one would likely say are pretty impressive upon first listen of GnR again. If anything, maybe it was 'ballad-heavy', and aside from them lacked a certain style or genre. When you add in Sorry, which I could see someone not believing too much in the rough cut, it coulda been too much of a ballad album, "Where's the rock?"
I forgot This I Love, but Better wasn't finished then it seems. Sorry/if the world may or may not be just an instrumental (claimed they are). Beavan isn't credited for vocals on them.
You have:
Atlas
Perhaps
Chinese Democracy
I.R.S.
The Blues
Madagascar
Catcher
Prostitute
Hardschool
There Was A Time
Ryiad
This I Love
Going Down
Oh My God
At the very least along with these tracks if you want to leave them off or not:
Silkworms
State of Grace
Eye on You
