You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
#761 Re: Guns N' Roses » Better, As it Began instrumentals » 373 weeks ago
Definitely siding with Axl.
The music was ready to be mixed and that was back when albums still sold well (Napster era, but nothing like today). It'd have sold several million copies by default, then everyone could have moved on.
Perhaps a reunion would have happened quicker or maybe Axl would have released more albums.
Better might not have been ready, but it was clear at least Atlas/Perhaps/Chinese Democracy/I.R.S./The Blues/Madagascar/Catcher/Ryiad/Prostitute/Hardschool/Silkworms/State of Grace were ready to mixed/mastered. You can argue that There Was A Time was heighted by Buckethead, but it could have been finished too nevermind other tracks their might be vocals on. Erzin was wrong.
Side note; Erzin is credited for track sequncing on the Fragile (Nine Inch Nails double album from 1999). If you've never heard it, State of Grace musically sounds heavily like it's from the same album.
#762 Re: Guns N' Roses » Better, As it Began instrumentals » 373 weeks ago
Finck plays alot of the best parts of these tracks that everyone seems to credit Bucket for.
#763 Re: Guns N' Roses » Drain the Swamp? » 373 weeks ago
Yeah msl needing cash doesn't add up if he's co-running mlw.
#764 Re: Guns N' Roses » Nothing from the "Rough Mixes 2" for now? » 373 weeks ago
Eye on You is supposed to be a demo (with vocals) like the others, Nothing is supposedly just Axl doing 1 line on repeat and Quick Song is no vocsls, just Axl making sounds???
Everything else is supposedly an instrumental (no vocals), however Madagascar is again supposedly just a better quality version of the one that leaked recently.
That doesn't mean there aren't copies of these tracks from a different source that'll leak at some point i.e. The General, Seven, Tonto ect.
#765 Re: Guns N' Roses » Better, As it Began instrumentals » 373 weeks ago
Anybody else think the piano tune may be Thyme?
Listed as different tracks:
#766 Re: Guns N' Roses » Better, As it Began instrumentals » 373 weeks ago
Again, is this Josh on drums on the early Better? If so, what a monster. Too bad he didn't stick around.
http://www.suicideshift.info/discograph … cd-085.png
Think this might be Brain, hard to tell. Unlike everything else this is listed as RTB era.
Doesn't mean it wasn't an earlier version.
#767 Re: Guns N' Roses » Better, As it Began instrumentals » 373 weeks ago
Better is interesting, since it's pre Bucket. Perhaps it's called 3 Dollar, because he hadn't wrote lyrics? It's another track (at least musically) that had origins earlier than thought.
On As It Began, it's easy to be dubious given there's no vocals. However I'll give it the benefit of the doubt. Does sound like an Axl driven track.
#768 Guns N' Roses » Better, As it Began instrumentals » 373 weeks ago
- AtariLegend
- Replies: 67
There's 2 supposed instrumentals leaked.
1 for 3 Dollar Pyramid (Better) and another being As it Began.
May or may not be real, instrumentals.
#769 Re: Guns N' Roses » Best song so far? » 373 weeks ago
Perhaps.
#770 Re: Guns N' Roses » Buckmaster-Beltrami on Chinese Democracy » 373 weeks ago
James wrote:what does this say about the status of Seven, Thyme, The General, and Leave Me Alone?
Leave Me Alone the working title for...?
http://www.gnrevolution.com/song.php?id=3107
Me, Myself and Elvis?
Which is supposed to be one of the tracks floating.
