He's been on a few times during the duration of this thread.

Even with the crappy drum machine beats it's still a killer song. It has the most illusion era feel to it of anything new I've heard. Not surprised it's winning.

I don't care if it is Prostitute or not. I think that it's  still a pretty good record either way. Personally I don't hear prostitute. To me it sounds like. "What I would do to have brought you down, myself". It's like he says it to've. Like he's saying "to" and "have" as a conjunction.

It seems like it's getting debated for the wrong reasons though. On one hand you have those who swear it's not prostitute because they think the best is yet to come. Then, on the other hand you have those who want it to be prostitute so they can prove their point that this album is just another record.

I like the song. It's no November Rain or Estranged, but it's still a good song. I can't believe that there's been no word from anybody about the title of the track. You'd think that someone (Axl's monkey boy Bach) would come out and at least tell us the fucking title.:P

I like what i've heard. Do they live up to the hype that's been surrounding them for years? No, but look at what they're up against. The bar has been set pretty high by AFD and UYI. I think that's what alot of people were expecting, the next UYI.

You got to keep in mind that we have very little info on these songs (new and the ones from last year) We don't know the dates of these demos ( they could be from around 02 or as I like to call it, the helium era), or how many of these will actually make the final track list. A few of these songs might be rejects that won't make any of the albums.

I think overall that they're good and could definately compete with the stuff that's at the top of the rock charts now. It's no AFD or UYI but I still enjoy them. Even if you hate these new songs, I think there will be something for everyone on CD. I'm still as excited as I was in 1999 .