I'm not sure why Incognito gets any credit.  It doesn't look like he did much of anything outside of begging.  If you're counting on him to produce something, you're wasting your time.

I don't listen to the song that often, but I do think it's a great song to end a live show with.  The end of the song is so high energy...it leaves you wanting more.  I wasn't a huge fan of the song when it came out, but appreciate it a lot more now since I didn't overplay it when it was out and I can appreciate the experience from a live perspective.

I said this in another thread.  I think Axl was holding BH back for whatever reason.  Maybe Axl though all he can do is shred?  I don't know.  I actually think had BH been allowed to take over Slash's role AND done so without killing the old songs, most Slash fans would have been more accepting of him and the new band.

I know it doesn't always come off this way, but I have a ton of respect for Axl musically.  Some of the songs he wrote on UYI are amazing, but I've always felt that his songs are usually complex in the lyrics and the section changes, but lacking a little in the complexity of the music itself.  While Slash favors straight forward rock and roll, look at what he did with NR, Estranged, Messages (just to say he can still do it), Patience (the acoustic guitar under the vocals while simple arpeggios on the surface give a feeling of texture to the song), etc show that he can (when he wants to) adapt his style to fit a style he doesn't prefer. 

The two were gold together.  Now the leaks lack the texture the old songs have, so Axl replaces texture with layer after layer of noise.  VR lacks the guy to set the song structure, so we have simple songs that don't inspire anything (with a few exceptions on both sides - I'm painting with a very broad brush here).  It shouldn't be Axl vs Slash.  They both brought something to the table that when put together created excellence (for the most part...again, a broad brush), but seperately both are missing something to take them to the next level. 

I know this will get the BH posse up in arms and that isn't my purpose.  BH brought a lot to the new band and probably saved it from extinction, but the magic (in the leaks at least) isn't nearly what Axl and Slash created together.