You are not logged in. Please register or login.

Rimov
 Rep: 10 

Re: GNR’s and SLASH’s performance of Paradise City in HELLFEST, France

Rimov wrote:

Here already mentioned that GNR and Slash both took part in HELLFEST, GNR at June, 16th at mainstage1, and Slash at June, 17th at mainstage2. Both of them have finished their sets  with Paradise City. It was interesting for me to compare video from fans.

IMHO GNR sounds much more powerful, provide better show and much more kick ass.

misterID
 Rep: 475 

Re: GNR’s and SLASH’s performance of Paradise City in HELLFEST, France

misterID wrote:

I think that has a lot to do that they've been doing it as a band longer. Plus, GN'R has three guitarists and Mother Goose wink

Slash's backing band isn't as tight as GN'R and, imo, aren't on Slash's level. And Jesus Christ, I can't stand Myles. If this was VR it'd be a lot more interesting comparison.

Smoking Guns
 Rep: 330 

Re: GNR’s and SLASH’s performance of Paradise City in HELLFEST, France

Smoking Guns wrote:

That is the worst sounding wah I have ever heard. Axl sounds fine, but Slash's guitar slays Ron's and DJ's.

Smoking Guns
 Rep: 330 

Re: GNR’s and SLASH’s performance of Paradise City in HELLFEST, France

Smoking Guns wrote:

[youtube]VMxOpjC7kJc&feature=youtube_gdata_player[/youtube]

Shall we compare this too?

-D-
 Rep: 231 

Re: GNR’s and SLASH’s performance of Paradise City in HELLFEST, France

-D- wrote:

GNR intro is fucking terrible.

monkeychow
 Rep: 661 

Re: GNR’s and SLASH’s performance of Paradise City in HELLFEST, France

monkeychow wrote:

I think I could some up my views on this thread like so:

I've never heard anyone play Slash's guitar parts as well as Slash does.

I've never heard anyone sing Axl's songs as well as Axl does.

I don't think I ever will.

misterID
 Rep: 475 

Re: GNR’s and SLASH’s performance of Paradise City in HELLFEST, France

misterID wrote:
-D- wrote:

GNR intro is fucking terrible.

Seriously? They fucking nailed that shit. Axl was spot on too, imo.

Dare I say, I'd love to hear Slash playing with THIS Gn'R line up.

Gibbo
 Rep: 191 

Re: GNR’s and SLASH’s performance of Paradise City in HELLFEST, France

Gibbo wrote:
Smoking Guns wrote:

[youtube]VMxOpjC7kJc&feature=youtube_gdata_player[/youtube]

Shall we compare this too?

16:haha:

-D-
 Rep: 231 

Re: GNR’s and SLASH’s performance of Paradise City in HELLFEST, France

-D- wrote:

helium Axl?

Guitar tones sounded bad, just sounded a half step slow and clunky

Bono
 Rep: 386 

Re: GNR’s and SLASH’s performance of Paradise City in HELLFEST, France

Bono wrote:
misterID wrote:
-D- wrote:

GNR intro is fucking terrible.

Seriously? They fucking nailed that shit. Axl was spot on too, imo.

Dare I say, I'd love to hear Slash playing with THIS Gn'R line up.

14 Yeah of course they did. Ummm..... NO. Gn'R's intro sounded fucking terrible. Off time and weak. Axl even blew the timing on blowing the whistle. Look at Axl's body language even he knows it sucked. Musically it was alright and Axl sounded ok at best but he sure as hell wasn't spot on. More out of breath than anything.

Slash's band performed it better. Stayed more true to the spirit of it, it was tighter and the intro was ten times better than Gn'R's. The outro was also better.  Myles sounded like Myles but to be honest he performs the song better live than Axl does these days. No different than SCOM.  Axl sounds out of breath all the time.

And hearing Slash play with this Gn'R would accomplish what? Four guitar players or you drop one and have Slash share duties with Ashba and Ron? Pointless.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB