You are not logged in. Please register or login.

Wagszilla
 Rep: 16 

Re: New Album Thread

Wagszilla wrote:

We have no idea what was kept from The Village sessions and later renamed so it’s all blind guess work.

James
 Rep: 644 

Re: New Album Thread

James wrote:

Good point.

For starters....

Why are the IRS instrumentals missing?

Edit

I thought you meant something missing from the leaks.

ClaudeF
 Rep: 11 

Re: New Album Thread

ClaudeF wrote:

Supposedly "Cuban Skies" was listed as the first song of "CD2" on a 2008 email that a certain GNR fan and wrassler obtained. "The General" was track two. In all, 21 songs made the list.

Supposedly.

wasted
 Rep: 4 

Re: New Album Thread

wasted wrote:
James wrote:

Good point.

For starters....

Why are the IRS instrumentals missing?

I get the impression there are no definitive demo discs. A few have surfaced but even from these we know Soul Monster has vocals now, Oklahoma has vocals and is now Berlin, so there’s probably more discs closer to CD finished product with Ron and Frank on them. Some of the CD songs are almost unrecognizable or at least very different from these. I’d never heard of Scraped or ITW, Sorry before CD came out. Also maybe no one has the actual CD II rough mixes so they are leaking 00s discs.

Wagszilla
 Rep: 16 

Re: New Album Thread

Wagszilla wrote:
James wrote:

Why are the IRS instrumentals missing?

It is curious.

No instrumentals for IRS, Riad, Catcher, If The World, or Prostitute from the finished album.

Or Atlas, Silkworms, Hard School, Perhaps, and State of Grace, the first of which was seemingly destined for it if not all of them.

It seems evidence would suggest these were the earliest session songs (Riad, IRS, Prostitute).

Hell, we don’t even have Brain on IRS yet.

James
 Rep: 644 

Re: New Album Thread

James wrote:
ClaudeF wrote:

Supposedly "Cuban Skies" was listed as the first song of "CD2" on a 2008 email that a certain GNR fan and wrassler obtained. "The General" was track two. In all, 21 songs made the list.

Supposedly.


21 songs.....and Tommy said a total of 22.

Was Silkworms taken out back and put out of its misery?

ClaudeF
 Rep: 11 

Re: New Album Thread

ClaudeF wrote:

"Silkworms" ("Silk H") was track 5.

Supposedly.

wasted
 Rep: 4 

Re: New Album Thread

wasted wrote:

Do we have the Beavan album? Stuff with just Finck and Tobias, pre Bucket?

If IRS etc is from 2000 intentions then that might explain no instrumental versions. Bucket came in a re-recorded and added some new tracks to it, but the vocals were from Beavan.

Cerulean wind
 Rep: -6 

Re: New Album Thread

Atlas has re - recorded vocals.
Hard School has now revamped lyrics.
Seven is "Estranged" tier.

zombux
 Rep: 36 

Re: New Album Thread

zombux wrote:
wasted wrote:

Do we have the Beavan album? Stuff with just Finck and Tobias, pre Bucket?

If IRS etc is from 2000 intentions then that might explain no instrumental versions. Bucket came in a re-recorded and added some new tracks to it, but the vocals were from Beavan.

yes, sort of we do have big part of that! count with me:

Catcher In The Rye
I.R.S.
There Was A Time
Atlas Shrugged
Perhaps
State of Grace
Prostitute
The Blues
Madagascar
Chinese Democracy
Rhiad & The Bedouins
Silkworms
likely also Nothing
likely also Hardschool
maybe also Eye on You

+ instrumentals:
Oklahoma
Quick Song
Zodiac
D-Tune
Curly Shuffle
maybe also Mustache
maybe also P.R.L.
maybe also Thyme

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB