You are not logged in. Please register or login.

Re: Guns N' Roses Without Dizzy Reed

AtariLegend wrote:

Would most of these songs sound Better or Worse without Keyboard parts....

Right Next Door to Hell
Live and Let Die
Don't Cry (Original) Or (Alternative)
Bad Obsession
November Rain
Civil War
14 Years
Yesterdays
Knockin' on Heaven's Door
Breakdown
Locomotive
So Fine
Estranged
There Was A Time
The Blues
Catcher In The Rye

A Private Eye
 Rep: 76 

Re: Guns N' Roses Without Dizzy Reed

I think in some of those songs keyboards are absoloutely necessary, imagine Estranged without the piano, it just wouldn't work imo. If Dizzy wasn't there Axl would be playing piano on the songs instead so it makes no difference really, we'd have got the same songs Dizzy or no Dizzy.

buzzsaw
 Rep: 426 

Re: Guns N' Roses Without Dizzy Reed

buzzsaw wrote:

I voted the same.  Dizzy didn't do anything special or create masterful piano parts.  Anybody could have done what he did, it just happened to be him.  I have nothing against Dizzy, I just don't think he's anything special either.

TheMole
 Rep: 74 

Re: Guns N' Roses Without Dizzy Reed

TheMole wrote:

I just love some rock&roll piano and think it fits even the harder songs in that list, so I think it would've been worse.

bringbackadler
 Rep: -10 

Re: Guns N' Roses Without Dizzy Reed

I voted the same.

I've always looked at Dizzy as being pretty useless overall to the GN'R sound and image.


bba

Re: Guns N' Roses Without Dizzy Reed

I put worse, I agree songs like Estranged, Yesterdays and November Rain would sound like Poo without the piano or keyboard.

buzzsaw
 Rep: 426 

Re: Guns N' Roses Without Dizzy Reed

buzzsaw wrote:
AtariLegend wrote:

Would most of these songs sound Better or Worse without Keyboard parts....

\This is a different question than the poll question.  I would answer this question worse.

Re: Guns N' Roses Without Dizzy Reed

AtariLegend wrote:
buzzsaw wrote:
AtariLegend wrote:

Would most of these songs sound Better or Worse without Keyboard parts....

\This is a different question than the poll question.  I would answer this question worse.

My mistake I should have worded it differently, although I still think Dizzy does a good job...

Neemo
 Rep: 480 

Re: Guns N' Roses Without Dizzy Reed

Neemo wrote:

i think all the UYI piano stuff was actually recorded by Axl, Dizzy was brought in after it was all done if I'm not mistaken

so i picked that it would be the same

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB