You are not logged in. Please register or login.

Axlin16
 Rep: 768 

Re: Chinese Democracy Liner Note Discussions *EXTREME SPOILERS*

Axlin16 wrote:

It's never been a band.

Guns N' Roses the band ended July 1993.


Guns N' Roses the musical entity continues today.

chicken_dinner
 Rep: 19 

Re: Chinese Democracy Liner Note Discussions *EXTREME SPOILERS*

why 1993? why not when adler left? or izzy (the main songwriter of old gnr)?

what happened in 1993?

the opinions are getting very similar to mygnr and htgth here nowadays LOL.

daviebuckethead
 Rep: 1 

Re: Chinese Democracy Liner Note Discussions *EXTREME SPOILERS*

^^^

i suppose in between 93 and 95 the bulk of what was no commerically as the most succeful GnR parted ways.

I dont think opinions are getting like htgth either, said the band ceased to exist in 93, it would get pulled asap.

Axlin16
 Rep: 768 

Re: Chinese Democracy Liner Note Discussions *EXTREME SPOILERS*

Axlin16 wrote:
chicken_dinner wrote:

why 1993? why not when adler left? or izzy (the main songwriter of old gnr)?

what happened in 1993?

the opinions are getting very similar to mygnr and htgth here nowadays LOL.

Adler was never a contributing force in the band.


The bulk of the band was still a band, the same ones who did AFD, Lies, the Illusions & TSI were kickin' in '93. Hell even Izzy did a few shows subbing for Gilby.

The 'band' died in 1993, back when the final show happened in Buenos Aires.


Even though the agreement basically made them employees in 1991, they still had equal shares in the partnership. Somesthing that I could not imagine anyone from the new band has any part of.

They are probably paid for their work in studio and on tour, like salaried employees, but full ownership on every level is W. Axl Rose.

I think the people here who read my posts on a daily basis, know how much I love the new band and want them to succeed. But there's nothing about new GN'R that comes across as a band. Just like nothing with NIN feels like a 'band'.

strat0
 Rep: 13 

Re: Chinese Democracy Liner Note Discussions *EXTREME SPOILERS*

strat0 wrote:
Axlin08 wrote:
chicken_dinner wrote:

why 1993? why not when adler left? or izzy (the main songwriter of old gnr)?

what happened in 1993?

the opinions are getting very similar to mygnr and htgth here nowadays LOL.

Adler was never a contributing force in the band.


The bulk of the band was still a band, the same ones who did AFD, Lies, the Illusions & TSI were kickin' in '93. Hell even Izzy did a few shows subbing for Gilby.

The 'band' died in 1993, back when the final show happened in Buenos Aires.


Even though the agreement basically made them employees in 1991, they still had equal shares in the partnership. Somesthing that I could not imagine anyone from the new band has any part of.

They are probably paid for their work in studio and on tour, like salaried employees, but full ownership on every level is W. Axl Rose.

I think the people here who read my posts on a daily basis, know how much I love the new band and want them to succeed. But there's nothing about new GN'R that comes across as a band. Just like nothing with NIN feels like a 'band'.

Yes but at least with GN'R you actually have more than 2 musicians working on an album. (the latest NIN album doesn't count. 16 that was more of a jab IMO)

Axlin16
 Rep: 768 

Re: Chinese Democracy Liner Note Discussions *EXTREME SPOILERS*

Axlin16 wrote:

Maybe the phrase is Axl doesn't allow them to "operate like a band".

'Cause Paul, Bucket, and Chris to name a few, had heavy contributions to this album. As much, or near as much as Axl himself.

Pine Barrens
 Rep: 0 

Re: Chinese Democracy Liner Note Discussions *EXTREME SPOILERS*

Pine Barrens wrote:

I would like to take a peek at this....

Re: Chinese Democracy Liner Note Discussions *EXTREME SPOILERS*

Sky Dog wrote:

Writing Credits .... number wise

1. Rose-14
2. Tobias-4
3. Reed-3
   Bucket-3
4. Stinson-2
    Costanzo-2
   Mantia-2
   Scaturro-2
   Pitman -2
5. Finck-1
   Freese-1

sic.
 Rep: 150 

Re: Chinese Democracy Liner Note Discussions *EXTREME SPOILERS*

sic. wrote:

Has anyone noticed the man who mastered CD?

Bob Ludwig. Credits include:

Led Zeppelin II & Houses of Holy
The Rolling Stones (complete Virgin + ABKCO records catalog)
Jimi Hendrix The Cry of Love 
Bruce Springsteen Almost Entire catalog
Nirvana Entire catalog (re-issues)
Pearl Jam Most catalog

And a TON of other albums. The dude's a legend.

monkeychow
 Rep: 661 

Re: Chinese Democracy Liner Note Discussions *EXTREME SPOILERS*

monkeychow wrote:

That's good. Hopefully no Clipping then!!

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB