You are not logged in. Please register or login.

Rimov
 Rep: 10 

Re: The Spin 79 - Guns songs ranked

Rimov wrote:

Here is totally different list. The same is only #1.
http://ultimateclassicrock.com/guns-n-r … gs-ranked/

Which list is better in your opinion?

polluxlm
 Rep: 221 

Re: The Spin 79 - Guns songs ranked

polluxlm wrote:

^ Much better list. Can't fault it really.

James
 Rep: 664 

Re: The Spin 79 - Guns songs ranked

James wrote:
Rimov wrote:

Here is totally different list. The same is only #1.
http://ultimateclassicrock.com/guns-n-r … gs-ranked/

Which list is better in your opinion?

It's a good list but has some faults as well.  Buick Makane at #78?  Buick Makane is one of my favorite TSI tracks. The Big Dumb Sex outro is lame but the rest of it kicks ass.

Their description of Scraped describes a lot of Chinese Democracy...

"Scraped" often sounds like two or three tracks that have been forced to get along.


Oh My God better than One In A Million? 18

I'd rank the title track CD a bit higher than 44.



Dust N Bones at 40?

person-smoking-crack-o.gif



It's so Easy at a respectable 11 but obviously I'd place it higher.

The top 3 is too predictable but EXACTLY the top 3 songs these stadium/festival crowds will want to hear the most...Jungle-PC-SCOM

polluxlm
 Rep: 221 

Re: The Spin 79 - Guns songs ranked

polluxlm wrote:
James Lofton wrote:

It's a good list but has some faults as well.  Buick Makane at #78?  Buick Makane is one of my favorite TSI tracks. The Big Dumb Sex outro is lame but the rest of it kicks ass.

Well, under appreciating a song James Lofton and five others like can hardly be called a fault. 13

BM is cool, but really how many are below it?

Their description of Scraped describes a lot of Chinese Democracy...

"Scraped" often sounds like two or three tracks that have been forced to get along.

One of my favorite songs, but I have to admit the description is spot on.

Oh My God better than One In A Million? 18

Sure, why not. OMG is not a bad song, and some of the lyrics in Million is enough to raise a stink about it.

I'd rank the title track CD a bit higher than 44.

Dust N Bones at 40?

The top 50 would be really hard overall for me since I think they have an abundance of great songs. I love CD, I love My Michelle and I love Breakdown. Their ranking on a list would feel arbitrary.

The very top and the bottom is easier.

tejastech08
 Rep: 194 

Re: The Spin 79 - Guns songs ranked

tejastech08 wrote:

My World is extremely overrated in that list while My Michelle, Paradise City, and Rocket Queen get the short stick from those writers. How the fuck can anyone put My World ahead of My Michelle? Hipster bullshit.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB