I also agree there James

I'm just saying that based on the size of the resume, the following is incredible....even for us oldtimers 14 years after the band tanked we still come around every day waiting for this fucking guy to release new material or even speak in the media

something definately stuck with us, maybe its the fact that for that time period there was no better or bigger band, I dunno, but there is somethign about them

I remember an interview with Duff on the radio after UYI were released about how GNR ranked with led zep and the beatles...and he pretty much said the same as you just did, even at their height of fame. the bottom line is that over the lifetime of orig gnr, they have a very small catalogue, but how about quality over quantity? like a percentage of hits vs the percentage of songs released, i'm sure GNR is near the top of any list of bands in that sense