again the circumstances are different

and i agree that it is a crazy niotion but if axl cant get bucket and finck back, the two most important contributers of the project are potentially gone. this is as good a chance at a reunion as they are gonna get unless they do it after the project fails which gnr/managment/label will do anything to avoid due to the money invested.

if i could clarify something in hopes of both a better understanding as to how you guys feel and to further eccentuate the variety of thoughts by asking this...............

what kind of reunion are we all thinking when we use the term?

there's reuniting for one big show like VMA's or something like that.

or there is a reunion tour

or there is reuniting as band and putting out records

Bucket:
yes i am glad bucket was in gnr. he clearly had the most to offer the project that i feel will bring us hours of listening pleasure when it is released. whether us bucket fans want to admit it or not, bucket was a nobody before he joined gnr. yes, he could have put out more albums had he not joined gnr but nobody would have known to listen to them.

The rest of the past members (not including finck):
could give or take

Robin Finck:
yes i am glad finck was in gnr. has stayed active with both NIN and GNR over the past several years so he's gotten plenty exposure and money (i am assuming he will appear on relased gnr music sooner than later). he has contributed some soulful music to the leaks. will make cd better. IMO robin is still open to touring with gnr when he is finished with nin.

some of you guys forget that these are adults we are talking about . they are responsible for their own decisions. if their careers are being wasted it is noboidy's fault but their own (not cd's).

pretty stupid if you ask me

rock band would not take a "throw-away song". it's hard enough for a brand new song as it is to earn it's spot on the list. this song will be great and that's not mindless optimism.

gnr won't make money off of a single alone and i am guessing axl isn't getting paid a ton of money for one song on rock band so common sense would say that they are promoting the album and/or another tour. i don't know if one song on a video game will help them sell seats for a third tour without an album. if anything the fact that their two most relevant guitarists are awol means that they are less likely to tour sooner than later. if anything, the album is coming but the lineup situation is holding up the album. that is if you beleive what axl said on the website.

as far as dizzy - i am already tired of reading about his band. mysteron said they are trying to get the album out this year. russ said it's on uni's release list. nothing official yet so the earliest we woulsd see it is november. what the fuck difference does it make that dizzy is plying a couple of shows in october????????