I would not be surprised if there are many atrocities. But this "poor me" image they are trying to sell about Israel is a crock of shit. I've seen politicians over there gloating about killing women and children, and when called on it, they just double down. You think the left are mad? Try the right over in Israel. Fucking hell.

Seems clear who is doing most of the killing. Hamas staging attacks on Israel should not come as a surprise. Clearly Israel is not interested in solving the issue peacefully and that means war.

So you get stuff like this. Now Israel is probably going to kill tens of thousands in response. And that will be "good".

Mitch asks a good question. Who are the good guys? I don't see anybody worth supporting. People yes, but not governments, religions, political agendas. Partisan nonsense all of it.

Yes probably something like that.

Still doesn't make any sense. People aren't suddenly going to buy the vinyl just because it's not on itunes. How many people even have a turn table? If you want the vinyl you are going to get it no matter what. All they're doing with this is to encourage pirating.

Did you like it? I liked the fourth, but I'm probably not watching this.

My first impressions.

Speak To Me/Breathe is as you say great, maybe the only song you could say is truly better than the original.

On The Run has great music but this is a talky song which brings it down.

Time is a wonderful version.

Great Gig In The Sky is probably the song that is hardest to fit into this scheme. You can't really replace those vocals with anything and still have it be epic. Still a good effort.

Money is another great version. Some parts are better than the original, some are not.

Us And Them is pretty good, not fantastic.

Any Colour You Like, Brain Damage and Eclipse are all great.

It's out now. Just gave it a listen.

I say it's a masterpiece. Not better or replacing the original but complementing it. That was young men, this is one old man. The musical landscape is truly marvelous, and the rumor that Waters was talking lyrics over the solos is not really true. On all the important bits he lets the music do the talking.