You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
#5971 The Sunset Strip » Most Famous Bass Players » 921 weeks ago
- buzzsaw
- Replies: 22
Another Stinson debate has led me to starting this thread. In most bands, the bass player is basically a support player along with the drummer and out of the spotlight. Who are the most famous bass players in the history of rock? By famous, I mean someone the general public would know as a musician.
Short list off the top of my head:
Paul McCartney (more famous for his singing and songwriting)
Flea (maybe in the 90s, not sure anymore)
Gene Simmons (though I think most think he plays guitar)
Sting (more famous for his singing)
A few I know that the general public likely doesn't:
Mike Dirnt
Duff
Tommy Stinson
Michael Anthony
I know I'm missing some of the older guys like Roger Waters...name some other famous bass players from any era.
#5972 Re: The Garden » Obama takes lead in polls » 921 weeks ago
All the talk now means nothing.
#5973 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N Roses on Universal Music Group Release List » 921 weeks ago
buzzsaw wrote:I do find it somewhat humorous that we're debating a reunion lineup at this point.
Only somewhat humorous?
Yes, only somewhat. Part of me thinks it's pretty sad.
#5974 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N Roses on Universal Music Group Release List » 921 weeks ago
buzzsaw wrote:Calling him a yes man isn't any more out of place than calling him a rock star.
This statement, in addition to your insinuation that Hootie and the Blowfish are a staples of modern rock radio, puts your credibility in grave danger. Tommy Stinson not only is a rock star, he is a natural rock star. For God's sake, he's played in two of the most influential bands of the last twenty years, and is on a few of the top 100 most influential rock albums (see The Replacements in wiki or google for a briefer) ever made. My God....
http://www.treblezine.com/reviews/195.html
In the liner notes of the Replacements' compilation record, All For Nothing, Jim Dickinson, the producer of Pleased to Meet Me had this to say about Tommy: "I want to say this about Tommy: Some people say that Keith Richards is the embodiment of rock and roll. Well, I know `em both and I say it's Tommy Stinson. Keith is a cowboy, he goes back to Gene Autry. Tommy'”he goes back to Johnny Thunders. Tommy Stinson is rock and roll." Amen.
Not many people in rock and roll have as storied a past and as dramatic a career as Tommy Stinson. For starters, Tommy was a founding member of the über-influential band the Replacements at the age of thirteen! Check it again, do the math. Tommy was born in '66 and the band formed in '79. Not only that, he had to play an integral part in the firing of his older brother Bob from the band due to alcohol and drug addiction and also his resistance to go into a mainstream direction. Deal with that, Gallagher brothers! Setting aside the hypocrisy of a partying band from firing Bob (it's kinda like firing a pornstar for acquiring an STD), after the increasing commercialism of the music led to Paul Westerberg's solo career, brother Bob died at the age of 35. Tommy formed his own bands upon the demise of the `Mats, first Bash and Pop, and later Perfect. Today he is better known for backing up P. Diddy on the "All About the Benjamins" remix and for being the `replacement' bass player for the new incarnation of Guns `n' Roses. Whoa.
So the liner notes of an album he plays on and 2 guys at a GnR site say he's a rock star? I'm going to need a little bit better sources than that. Nice try, but he is not, nor was he ever a star. Therefore, by definition, he was never and never will be a rock star. Thank you and have a nice day.
I don't understand why the couple Stinson fans take that as an insult. There are very few true rock stars out there, and there might be a handful of them that play bass. Not being a rock star doesn't mean he sucks...it just means nobody (meaning the general public for the people waiting to pick this apart) knows who he is.
#5975 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N Roses on Universal Music Group Release List » 921 weeks ago
I do find it somewhat humorous that we're debating a reunion lineup at this point.
#5976 Re: Guns N' Roses » Guns N Roses on Universal Music Group Release List » 921 weeks ago
Calling him a yes man isn't any more out of place than calling him a rock star.
#5977 Re: Guns N' Roses » Stinson bailed? NME rumor. » 921 weeks ago
Well, if Beta said so, it must be true!!!! All hail Priestess Beta!
#5978 Re: Guns N' Roses » Stinson bailed? NME rumor. » 921 weeks ago
I think the realistic reunion scenario is CD release as more or less an Axl solo project (even if it's under the name GnR) and a reunion shortly thereafter. If VR wanted a lead singer, they'd have one. Slash is finishing his solo album while this is going on and then they're both available.
#5979 Re: The Garden » Good day, friends. » 921 weeks ago
This is gay.
#5980 Re: The Garden » Jake "The Snake" Implodes » 921 weeks ago
It would be sadder if this was a stunt set up by wrestling. I wouldn't put anything past them...

