I agree with this. There’s been plenty of big shows in the past. It’s always the same safe set list.

Atlas feels completely done to me.

Perhaps feels like it needs a few final touches. Some of the vocal cuts feel off to me during the chorus.

Either song is good though.

I'm late to the convo, but...

I think the album in 2000 would have sold enough to keep the lineup together. To inspire them to create new songs together. To get people used to the new GNR.

Build a new fanbase. Etc.

The exact amount it would have sold isn't too important. Releasing in 2000 would have allowed another album and some band cohesion at least.

PMMMMMMMMMMMMMM.

I want to hear them badly . Thank you to any who help!

EDIT: Nevermind! James had good advice about reddit. Don't know why I didn't think of that...

So does the remastered stuff sound considerably better than the old stuff?

Anyone give it a listen yet? I haven't followed recently so I'm unsure if it's out already.