You are not logged in. Please register or login.

Re: Tracks on the album better than the Rough Mixes

Sky Dog wrote:
James wrote:
Sky Dog wrote:

Tracks better on album TWAT, IRS and Prostitute. bucket


The president of the Tommy Stinson fan club prefers album versions? tongue

Very true!!!....you got me there. Fantasyland world has Bucket inserted on the 2000 rough mixes versions.
tommy 13

davegnfnr2k
 Rep: 0 

Re: Tracks on the album better than the Rough Mixes

davegnfnr2k wrote:

nothing on the album is better than the rough cuts or early demos.
the more Axl worked on the songs the worse than got
the album would have been a million times better if it was the 2001/02 version

Also the stuff I want to hear is the stuff that BH did before he was removed to add Finck back on some of the songs.
As well as a vocal version of all those instrumentals.

davegnfnr2k
 Rep: 0 

Re: Tracks on the album better than the Rough Mixes

davegnfnr2k wrote:
Wagszilla wrote:
elevendayempire wrote:

Couldn't you just plop the vocals from the Rock Band multitracks onto the instrumental demo of Sorry? Sure, it'd be a Frankenstein's monster and not a "real" demo, but needs must...

It wouldn't work.

The guitar would drown out the main chorus.

I really wish "Sorry" had an alternative cut with better lyrics ala "Don't Cry (alt)".

it does work wink

AgesOfTheIce
 Rep: 0 

Re: Tracks on the album better than the Rough Mixes

AgesOfTheIce wrote:
James wrote:
Wagszilla wrote:

I really wish "Sorry" had an alternative cut with better lyrics ala "Don't Cry (alt)".

This is why I will never bother listening to a fan edit of including the vocals on the demo.

The instrumental has a chilling doom and gloom, existential vibe to it.

It deserved so much more than being a song aimed at Slash and other "enemies".

I wish Bucket or someone had stood up to him and said that the lyrics aren't acceptable.

Having said that....

It’s harder to live with the truth about you, than to live with the lies about me’ is absolute gold.

One of his best lines ever.

I kinda disagree with this. I think what makes Axl a great songwriter is how personal he is, and we know his hatred of Slash was a major obsession of his for almost two decades.  I would rather he write about what he's feeling than try to write something more substantive if he's not into it. Sorry might come off as petty but he's pouring his emotions out there.

davegnfnr2k
 Rep: 0 

Re: Tracks on the album better than the Rough Mixes

davegnfnr2k wrote:
AgesOfTheIce wrote:
James wrote:
Wagszilla wrote:

I really wish "Sorry" had an alternative cut with better lyrics ala "Don't Cry (alt)".

This is why I will never bother listening to a fan edit of including the vocals on the demo.

The instrumental has a chilling doom and gloom, existential vibe to it.

It deserved so much more than being a song aimed at Slash and other "enemies".

I wish Bucket or someone had stood up to him and said that the lyrics aren't acceptable.

Having said that....

It’s harder to live with the truth about you, than to live with the lies about me’ is absolute gold.

One of his best lines ever.

I kinda disagree with this. I think what makes Axl a great songwriter is how personal he is, and we know his hatred of Slash was a major obsession of his for almost two decades.  I would rather he write about what he's feeling than try to write something more substantive if he's not into it. Sorry might come off as petty but he's pouring his emotions out there.


sorry has some really cringe lyrics
like i don't want to do it
or ill kick your ass like I said

the chorus is great but that is about it
some of the lyrics are good but at least 50% could be better.

BHs great guitar work was wasted.

Geffen
 Rep: 0 

Re: Tracks on the album better than the Rough Mixes

Geffen wrote:

I think only Rhiad.

mitchejw
 Rep: 115 

Re: Tracks on the album better than the Rough Mixes

mitchejw wrote:
davegnfnr2k wrote:
AgesOfTheIce wrote:
James wrote:

This is why I will never bother listening to a fan edit of including the vocals on the demo.

The instrumental has a chilling doom and gloom, existential vibe to it.

It deserved so much more than being a song aimed at Slash and other "enemies".

I wish Bucket or someone had stood up to him and said that the lyrics aren't acceptable.

Having said that....



One of his best lines ever.

I kinda disagree with this. I think what makes Axl a great songwriter is how personal he is, and we know his hatred of Slash was a major obsession of his for almost two decades.  I would rather he write about what he's feeling than try to write something more substantive if he's not into it. Sorry might come off as petty but he's pouring his emotions out there.


sorry has some really cringe lyrics
like i don't want to do it
or ill kick your ass like I said

the chorus is great but that is about it
some of the lyrics are good but at least 50% could be better.

BHs great guitar work was wasted.

Isn’t it more the way he says ‘i don’t want to do it’?

Re: Tracks on the album better than the Rough Mixes

Sky Dog wrote:

I think that is actually funny....

davegnfnr2k
 Rep: 0 

Re: Tracks on the album better than the Rough Mixes

davegnfnr2k wrote:
mitchejw wrote:
davegnfnr2k wrote:
AgesOfTheIce wrote:

I kinda disagree with this. I think what makes Axl a great songwriter is how personal he is, and we know his hatred of Slash was a major obsession of his for almost two decades.  I would rather he write about what he's feeling than try to write something more substantive if he's not into it. Sorry might come off as petty but he's pouring his emotions out there.


sorry has some really cringe lyrics
like i don't want to do it
or ill kick your ass like I said

the chorus is great but that is about it
some of the lyrics are good but at least 50% could be better.

BHs great guitar work was wasted.

Isn’t it more the way he says ‘i don’t want to do it’?

I am not sure even if he sang that line normally it would come off well.

BLS-Pride
 Rep: 208 

Re: Tracks on the album better than the Rough Mixes

BLS-Pride wrote:
davegnfnr2k wrote:
AgesOfTheIce wrote:
James wrote:

This is why I will never bother listening to a fan edit of including the vocals on the demo.

The instrumental has a chilling doom and gloom, existential vibe to it.

It deserved so much more than being a song aimed at Slash and other "enemies".

I wish Bucket or someone had stood up to him and said that the lyrics aren't acceptable.

Having said that....



One of his best lines ever.

I kinda disagree with this. I think what makes Axl a great songwriter is how personal he is, and we know his hatred of Slash was a major obsession of his for almost two decades.  I would rather he write about what he's feeling than try to write something more substantive if he's not into it. Sorry might come off as petty but he's pouring his emotions out there.


sorry has some really cringe lyrics
like i don't want to do it
or ill kick your ass like I said

the chorus is great but that is about it
some of the lyrics are good but at least 50% could be better.

BHs great guitar work was wasted.

   

Agreed here. Such a great bluesy solo. I always thought the forever and a day line in prostitute was cringe too.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB