You are not logged in. Please register or login.

Re: Ideal Setlist Part 2: Coma vs. There Was A Time

AtariLegend wrote:

As with the previous choice, the only time There Was A Time has been played this tour is when Coma has been dropped.

Both are extremely popular tracks, however I'd imagine Coma might win this one. If you're wondering however, There Was A Time has never been a set-list regular.

I'm voting There Was A Time, along with Estranged it's my favorite track.

Which would you prefer?

Coma 73%
There Was A Time 27%
Total votes: 30
chad4bama
 Rep: 2 

Re: Ideal Setlist Part 2: Coma vs. There Was A Time

chad4bama wrote:

Coma...not even close.

Smoking Guns
 Rep: 327 

Re: Ideal Setlist Part 2: Coma vs. There Was A Time

Smoking Guns wrote:

Coma... CD songs just aren't great live but Twat is a great song.

faldor
 Rep: 280 

Re: Ideal Setlist Part 2: Coma vs. There Was A Time

faldor wrote:

Tough one, but I went with Coma. Can't lose either way.

bigbri
 Rep: 329 

Re: Ideal Setlist Part 2: Coma vs. There Was A Time

bigbri wrote:

Coma, love the outro.

buzzsaw
 Rep: 426 

Re: Ideal Setlist Part 2: Coma vs. There Was A Time

buzzsaw wrote:

I voted TWAT, but only because I've seen Coma 5 times and TWAT only once, and that was with no Slash or BH.

-Jack-
 Rep: 37 

Re: Ideal Setlist Part 2: Coma vs. There Was A Time

-Jack- wrote:

Coma anyday.

monkeychow
 Rep: 634 

Re: Ideal Setlist Part 2: Coma vs. There Was A Time

monkeychow wrote:

Tough one...Coma is GNR's most unique song....TWAT has Axl's best vocal performance in those screams.

Although I understand Atari's reasoning in putting these two against each other, I think the band themselves would be more logical to alternate Estranged and Twat - as they're similar songs - lengthy ballads made rocky with sizable guitar parts.

At this stage I think there's more good Coma footage than Twat footage so for a few shows at least I'd like it swapped around until someone films an epic version for me wink

harmon420
 Rep: 17 

Re: Ideal Setlist Part 2: Coma vs. There Was A Time

harmon420 wrote:

Voted Coma.

Tough call to make since they are both epic songs. The outro on Coma imo, is one of the greatest GN'R moments in their entire discography. Although there are moments in TWAT I could just as easily regard as pure greatness.

Ragnar
 Rep: 8 

Re: Ideal Setlist Part 2: Coma vs. There Was A Time

Ragnar wrote:

I`ll go with TWAT.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB