You are not logged in. Please register or login.

Re: The Best of Rough Mixes Disc 1, Elimination Series Round 3

AtariLegend wrote:

Vote for your least favorite track. The track with the most votes will be eliminated.

*In the event of a tie in the earlier rounds, all tied tracks will be lost. No tie breaker, until the later stages.*

This is based on Rough Mixes Disc 1 only, not any other demo or the album copy.

Voting closes in 2 days.

Vote off your least favorite track

Madagascar 4%
There Was A Time 33%
Atlas Shrugged 15%
Perhaps 4%
Prostitute 15%
Catcher in the Rye 11%
Chinese Democracy 7%
The Blues 11%
Total votes: 27
James
 Rep: 625 

Re: The Best of Rough Mixes Disc 1, Elimination Series Round 3

James wrote:

Damn. Riad didn't deserve such an early exit. It was one of two bad ass rockers on this early version of the album.

I gotta vote Prostitute again. Even though it's better here than it was on the actual album, it just doesn't do much for me and besides, it becomes redundant in the mix with The Blues, Madagascar, and TWAT.

Re: The Best of Rough Mixes Disc 1, Elimination Series Round 3

AtariLegend wrote:

I'm not sure on this vote.

The Blues, Catcher in the Rye, Perhaps and Chinese Democracy are the best versions of each available. Madagascar might be too.

I really like this version of Atlas, despite not being too fond of the first leak.

That leaves Prostitute and There Was A Time. TWAT is my favourite track on the album and one of my favourites in the entire back catalogue, however this isn't the best version of the track. I can't say that about the other tracks. I actually need to think on this one.

Vale
 Rep: 2 

Re: The Best of Rough Mixes Disc 1, Elimination Series Round 3

Vale wrote:

I'm gonna keep voting for Atlas. I just don't get into it.

Vincevega06
 Rep: 0 

Re: The Best of Rough Mixes Disc 1, Elimination Series Round 3

Vincevega06 wrote:

I’m also going to keep my vote as Catcher, I still always skip it off this disc lol

bigbri
 Rep: 328 

Re: The Best of Rough Mixes Disc 1, Elimination Series Round 3

bigbri wrote:

This TWAT sucks.

Izzyjim
 Rep: 1 

Re: The Best of Rough Mixes Disc 1, Elimination Series Round 3

Izzyjim wrote:
bigbri wrote:

This TWAT sucks.

Yeah, something in the mix is just.. wrong.
Can’t believe I’d voted for Prostitute, which sounds so different than the album version hmm

dalethirsty
 Rep: 18 

Re: The Best of Rough Mixes Disc 1, Elimination Series Round 3

dalethirsty wrote:

there was a time is pointless without bucket

it's like estranged with no slash

Re: The Best of Rough Mixes Disc 1, Elimination Series Round 3

AtariLegend wrote:

I still love this version of There Was A Time even without Bucket. Although obviously Bucket took it to another level at some point after this.

I was almost tempted to vote it off tbh too. I think in this form, the first verse comes across a little more self indulgent. ...But it's just great musically either way.

I voted off Atlas Shrugged, albeit with great hesitation.

benny
 Rep: 0 

Re: The Best of Rough Mixes Disc 1, Elimination Series Round 3

benny wrote:

After some debate, I voted off There Was A Time.  I do agree that the rough mixes disc 1 version blows the album version away.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB