You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
Re: Best song so far?
sp1at wrote:I think the ones with vocals will be better received first, pardon the pun
Nah we've been spoiled with vocals, seeing as there's allegedly only 3 left I say let the leaker drop all the instruments and finish up with a grand finale one two three Punch of the vocal songs
Ahh, I didn't know. It's all appreciated, so I'll go with your sentiment
- dalethirsty
- Rep: 20
Re: Best song so far?
state of grace:
the name sucks but the song is exactly the kind of weird ass shit i imagined axl was cooking up in the 90s. it's like a mechanical version of the garden.
the melody in the verses is the catchiest part from any of the new leaks, imo.
a version with buckethead guitars and proper vocals would be AMAZING!
atlas shrugged:
has a classic feel to it, kinda like yesterday's. axl's moaning during the verses is pretty annoying, though. seems like 2 songs glued together, but it's really growing on me.
perhaps:
the piano riff is the best part, especially when it comes in the 2nd time. axl's vocals and lyrics are pretty awful and the "chorus" doesn't really work for me. there's a great song somewhere in there, i think.
hard school:
this would have worked way better than oh my god as the first new gn'r song. chorus is great. is axl on guitar on this? slash and duff could turn this into a hit.
silkworms:
kinda jams actually! i miss the chorus. the drums are fucking killer.
- TimothyFirefly
- Rep: 0
Re: Best song so far?
State of Grace and Hard School for me. Don't really dig Atlas that much.
- TheSundanceKid
- Rep: 30
Re: Best song so far?
Um I read somewhere a leak of a new version of Knocking On Heaven's Door is circulating, is that correct?
- BlueJeanBaby
- Rep: 1
Re: Best song so far?
Um I read somewhere a leak of a new version of Knocking On Heaven's Door is circulating, is that correct?
Yes an acoustic version
I love Hard School and consider it the most traditional GNR song, but there's just something about Perhaps that makes me keep playing it 
- jimmythegent
- Rep: 30
Re: Best song so far?
I’m surprised it’s not been mentioned before - but anyone wondering how much Paul Huge’s fingerprints are on these leaks ?
If so, I wonder if it is a variable that Slash would consider if he were to work on it ?
